Rule of Photo-Ops and the Divine Right (Hand Side).

I have been waiting to write about the coup in Egypt in the past week, because such an unexpected and confusing event makes for bad snap-punditry. (My word choice here — “coup” — is one of the central, but inane, controversies of this rough-draft-style analysis. I think we can call what has been happening in Egypt since January 2011 an ongoing revolution, which has included many many protests. But the event that concerns us this week is a military coup). Contrary to David Brooks and the WSJ, no this event doesn’t mean Egyptians aren’t democratic or require “a Pinochet.” Nor does this event spell “the end of political Islam.” For those looking for the best of different styles of analysis that deal well with the current ambiguity, please see essays by: Nathan Brown (on institutions and tactics), Ellis Goldberg (on the Muslim Brotherhood), Sarah Carr (on the pro- and anti-Morsi crowds) and Walter Armbrust (on the Egyptian media).

I have merely a brief note today along the line of Armbrust’s interests: the manipulation of the mass media. When protesters complain about the “deep state,” they usually mean the hand of the military or Ministry of Interior in electoral politics. But there is another institution that has not been overthrown since the Mubarak era and before: the presidential photo pool. Take for example:

2013-635089910998087619-808This is brand-new Prime Minister Hazim al-Biblawi (on the left), a finance technocrat and former deputy prime minister under SCAF chairman Muhammad Hussein Tantawi (on the right), meeting today with “acting” President Adli Mansour, head of the Supreme Constitutional Court, who still has not spoken in public.

Morsi Qandil Pres.previewHere we have just-ousted Muslim Brotherhood Freedom and Justice Party President Muhammad Mursi (right) and his Prime Minister Hisham Qandil (left), probably taken around a year ago. It’s the same corner of the President’s office, same bright white flat flash lighting, the same chair and couch (before reupholstering), different tree in the same place, same coffee table, same phone, same kind of flowers, same paunches and same postures (on which more below).

kamal-el-ganzouri-mohamed-hussein-tantawi-2011-11-25-12-10-10Just prior to Mursi’s election, the governing pair were Tantawi (right) as head of state and Kamal al-Ganzouri (left) as prime minister, in the first half of 2012. Al-Ganzouri had been Hosni Mubarak’s prime minister from 1996 to 1999. This is a different part of the room, plus Tantawi gets all the armed forces’ service flags (not to mention a tiny national flag on the table, just in case). Tantawi remains in uniform, as he never became a civilian president.

But the message is the same in each image: there IS a government and hierarchy withstands all shocks. The photographer poses the more powerful man on the right, with his hands apart, making a gesture or ready to do so. The less powerful man (the prime minister) is sitting with legs together and hands folded in his lap ready to receive a command. These carefully constructed images are a reflection of the Egyptian constitution, in which a strong president has the unilateral right to choose his prime minister, who merely carries out the president’s plans. In the 2013 scenario, the military has wised up and made a senior judge the nominal president, maintaining a facade of civil government probably while reserving close veto powers over Mansour’s decisions.

I’m not claiming this recent coup has set the revolutionaries back to square one. Nor do I think that this school of propaganda photography is enslaving Egyptians to an anti-democratic political system. But there are institutions of the Egyptian state that run deeper and attract less notice than the usual suspects such as the riot police. These photos are effective tools, in a media environment still dominated by state-owned organs like Al-Gumhuriya, Al-Ahram and Channel 1, for numbing the public to the exercise of power with their placidity and repetitiveness. Whether it works in the long run is another matter.

I was unable to find an image of Mubarak sitting with one of his many PMs like the ones above, but I will leave you with the image below. Yes, that’s Israeli PM Benjamin Netanyahu. It’s the same chairs and same coffee table, and the same bogus message: Mubarak was in control.

1252862433318

About these ads

About ericschewe

An American PhD student in History living in Ann Arbor, Michigan. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 Unported License.
This entry was posted in Egypt. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Rule of Photo-Ops and the Divine Right (Hand Side).

  1. Erika says:

    Hi Eric,

    Thanks for your always timing analysis much needed on those critical times of Egyptian history.
    I am curious to know more with regard your last point, thus the photo of Ex. President Mubarak with the PM Benjamin Netanyahu.

    In particular I was wandering if by leaving us with this picture you meant something more that just confirming that there are institutions of power in the Egyptian government which do repeat themselves and are reinforced through different regimes. For example, does the last picture tells us something with regard the power that the Egyptian state has on the Israeli-Palestinian question? And how would we explain that despite the fact that Mursi assumed the same position of power when he was sitting with his nominated PM, the same underlying structures did not allow Ex. President Mursi to have a real power on the Egyptian government/military?

    By the way, I do agree with you that what happened in Egypt was at all effects a coup despite the fact that the international community apart form Germany, and including Egyptian people themselves refuse to acknowledge that. Apparently a majority of Egyptians protesting in Tahrir square claim that they called for the army to intervene and that the army saved their revolution.

    Thanks,

    Erika

  2. Sonya Baehr says:

    Fascinating analysis of body position, mis en scene, and gesture, Eric! Worthy of a theatre specialist! I’m glad you’re sending out posts again. I just had a conversation with a young man from Turkey today and he is quite optimistic about their situation. A much more active and informed population. Perhaps a more developed middle class.

    Best Regards, Sonya Baehr

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s